Contact us | Login | Become a Friend or Register for free
Mills Archive Trust logo

Home » Mill writing » Photo retouching

Mill writing

Photo retouching

February 11 2009 by Fred Atkins (1182 views)
Windmills | 1 comment

I copied Jenny West’s old postcard on Facebook and retouched it with my Picasa 3 program (free from Google). The result is as attached. Not perfect but an improvement aesthetically! I wonder if this is acceptable or would people rather see something less pleasing to the eye?

Continued below ...

Article Image

You never know with photos whether they have been retouched or not (illustrations in old mill books are often badly retouched, e.g. with the addition of sweeps that have vanished into the sky). In this case, I’ve not retouched anything to do with the mill itself, but as long as work done to it doesn’t actually change the details, I wouldn’t have thought it would matter.

The covering up of a white spot on some weatherboarding with a “patch” taken from another part of the tower would I guess be OK, but replacing a missing section of the boarding to pretty it up would be obviously undesirable.

The original image from the Mills Archive Facebook page can be seen at http://apps.facebook.com/myflickr/photos/40323207238/3134304738

Any comments appreciated.

Related articles

Star windmill Chatham


Did you enjoy this article? Share it with your friends

ASK Favicon del.icio.us Favicon Facebook Favicon Google Favicon LinkedIn Favicon Live Favicon Print Favicon Reddit Favicon TwitThis Favicon Webnews.de Favicon YahooMyWeb Favicon Email Favicon

Trackback URL:
http://www.millsarchivetrust.org/index.php/trackback/22761/elbwQvom/



Messages & comments

Default avata
Posted by .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)
Thu, February 12, 2009

Fred raises an interesting point. As an Archive we are very careful to present the best scan we can of the item as it really is. This can often means exquisite detail is not evident. Certainly many of the 35mm slides we have are far too dark and could do with lightening. Our angle is that users can always do that themselves, but we cannot necessarily get back to the original image without repeating the scan.

The balance between a picture gallery and an archive is challenging! In the case of Star Mill, the one under discussion, I was using it as an example of what can happen if people fail to give us material to look after.

Incidentally to make Mark's link work you need to login to the Mills Archive site before you click his link! You can also see it by clicking the link to the related article


Get involved

If you'd like to respond to this article, please use the form provided below.

Please note that your comments will need to be moderated first, so it might take a little while for your remarks to be published. If you'd like to avoid waiting for moderation, you will need to register first, or login if you've done this already.

You'll need to register or login first in order to leave a comment.

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Submit the word you see below: